Hit by a Delivery Driver in New Braunfels? Coverage Gets Messy
How insurance actually works when a gig or delivery driver causes your crash, and why the app status matters more than you'd think.
If a food delivery driver, rideshare car, or gig courier hit you on I-35, Loop 337, or anywhere else around New Braunfels, your claim isn't a simple two-insurance-company situation. Gig and delivery drivers often carry personal auto policies that exclude commercial activity, plus a separate layer of coverage from the app company that only applies during certain parts of the trip.
Figuring out which policy actually pays starts with one question: what was the app showing at the moment of the crash? Was the driver waiting for a delivery ping, actively en route to pick up food, or driving back home with the app closed? Each answer points to a different insurance layer, and that's the piece most people don't know to ask about.
Why gig driver crashes work differently
A regular personal auto policy is built around commuting and errands, not paid delivery runs. Many personal policies contain a livery or commercial-use exclusion, meaning the insurer can deny coverage entirely if the driver was working for a delivery app at the time of the crash.
To fill that gap, companies like the major delivery and rideshare platforms carry their own insurance policies for drivers using the app. But that coverage usually isn't a flat, always-on policy. It shifts depending on what stage of the delivery or ride the driver was in, which is why the app's trip status matters so much to your claim.
The three periods that decide which policy applies
App off: If the driver had the app closed or logged out, this is treated like any other personal drive. Their personal auto policy is what applies, subject to whatever limits and exclusions are in that policy.
App on, waiting for a request: Many platforms provide a limited layer of contingent coverage during this window, meaning it may only kick in if the driver's personal policy denies the claim or doesn't cover enough.
En route to pick up or during an active delivery or ride: This is typically when the platform's higher coverage applies most fully, since the driver is actively working. Exact structure and limits vary by company and change over time, so this is general information, not a guarantee of what any specific policy pays.
What this means if you were hit
You may end up dealing with more than one insurance company: the driver's personal insurer, the platform's insurer, and possibly your own if you carry uninsured motorist or med-pay coverage. It's common for each one to point at the others before anyone accepts responsibility for paying.
This doesn't mean you have no options. It means the claim takes more documentation and more patience, and it helps to have someone sorting out which policy is actually on the hook before you accept any offer.
Evidence that matters in these cases
Beyond the usual photos and police report, gig-driver crashes often turn on app data: trip history, timestamps, GPS pings, and whether the driver had an active delivery or ride assigned. That data typically lives with the platform and the driver's phone, not with either insurance company, and it can be harder to get later.
If you're able to safely note the app the driver was using, ask if they were on an active delivery, and get the name of the food or retail order if visible in their car, that small detail can save weeks of back-and-forth about which insurance layer applies.
Delivery vehicles also sometimes carry hot bags, branded signs, or dashboard placards. A quick photo of these, along with the driver's info, helps establish that they were working at the time, which matters for coverage.
If you're a gig or delivery driver yourself
The same layered coverage question applies if you were the one delivering or driving for an app when someone hit you. Your own personal insurer may try to deny the claim by pointing to the commercial-use exclusion, even though you weren't at fault for the crash.
In that situation, the platform's insurance may be the one responsible for your claim, but you'll likely need to show your app status at the time to access it. Keep screenshots or records of your trip activity when possible, since apps don't always retain that data indefinitely.
What to remember
- Note whether the delivery or rideshare driver's app was on, off, or showing an active trip as soon as possible after the crash.
- Expect to deal with more than one insurance company: personal, platform, and potentially your own uninsured motorist coverage.
- Photograph delivery bags, branding, or app screens in the vehicle if you can safely do so.
- Don't assume a denial from the driver's personal insurer is the final word, another coverage layer may apply.
- Gig platform trip data can be time-sensitive, so try to preserve it or get it requested early.
Common questions
What if the delivery driver says their insurance won't cover a work trip?
That's common, since many personal policies exclude commercial delivery use. It usually means the platform's own insurance layer needs to be brought into the claim instead, which requires showing the driver's app status at the time of the crash.
Does it matter if the driver was delivering food versus giving a ride?
The general layered-coverage structure, app off, waiting, and active trip, applies across most delivery and rideshare platforms, though the specific limits and rules differ by company. It's worth identifying which app was involved early on.
Can I still file a claim if I don't know which app the driver was using?
Yes, the police report, the driver's insurance information, and any visible branding on the car can often help identify it later. It's just easier and faster if you can note it at the scene.
This article is general information for the public, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Nothing here predicts an outcome or the value of any claim. Laws and filing deadlines differ by state and change over time — talk with a lawyer about your own situation. Attorney advertising.
Need help in New Braunfels?
Tell us what happened. There is no cost to speak with our team, and in-person meetings are available by appointment.